Comment on Gartner Storage Best Practices for Hosted Virtual Desktops
Thursday, 11 November 2010 by Michel Roth

 This research examines storage best practices for hosted virtual desktop deployments by Gartner. Some stuff I violently disagree with. 

The article has some very good information in it, at a 20,000 feet view of course. One of the reasons why I think this article is incomplete, is that there is no mention of using local storage (note that the URL has 'Netapp' in it so guess who was sponsoring that :-)). Why on earth would you NEED to use SAN storage in VDI? That is almost the same thing as upgrading a company lease car plan so everyone can drive a Ferrari. 

Which brings me to my next point. One of the quotes is "To avoid simultaneous outages of all virtual desktops, users should specify, configure, and operate storage for the highest levels of data protection and availability. Technology and practice for recovery from logical failures must be selected for appropriate RPO and RTO."

I think there needs to be a very important distinciton here: only use this DR functionality for data that matters: user data. Please dont waste money on replicating and snapshotting OS Data unless you NEED to. You probably NEED to do this when you are using persistent desktops. Want to drive costs down? Make sure that you use as many pooled desktops as you can. Want to drive costs down even further? Use Terminal Server if you can. That is not a joke - it is actual advice.

here's the original Gartner doc (which is still recommended reading): http://goo.gl/btoIY


Related Items:

Demo of Quest vWorkspace With NetApp Storage Integration (18 September 2009)
Storage Efficiency: Multi-Layering of Deduplication (5 August 2009)
Sneak Preview - NetApp RCU 3.0 (7 December 2009)
Quest Software Virtualization Group Speeds VDI Adoption With New Edition of Quest vWorkspace (9 September 2009)
Hosting Virtual Desktop On XenExpress (11 January 2008)
NetApp Data Motion (31 August 2009)
Solid State Disk will change the storage world (2 November 2009)
Integrating ThinApp packages with VMware View - (Part 2) (19 October 2009)
Virtual Desktops: Expanding our Integration (21 August 2009)
Get Thin Provisioning working for you in vSphere (26 October 2009)
Comments (0)