Will Citrix (Be Able To) Keep ICA?
Tuesday, 04 March 2008 by Michel Roth
Ever since Microsoft announced their acquisition of Calista Technologies there have been sounds that this spells the end of ICA. After all, Calista promises to deliver a much richer multimedia experience than ICA will ever be able to do (unless Citrix very drastically changes the way ICA works). These rumors are of course resonated by Citrix competition...

Warren Ponder, a Senior Technical Marketing Engineer at VMware, is one of these individuals that also (not surprisingly - VMware and Citrix have been exchanging "emotions" quite frequently recently) feels that Calista poses a threat to ICA (to say the least). In his blog, Warren also discusses the consequence of another action by Microsoft that got relatively little attention: the publication of the specifications of a LOT of Windows client and server protocols . I say LOT because it's over 30,000 pages of information. One of the protocols that is also covered is RDP. Everything you ever wanted to know (or did not want to know) is now publicly available.

Warren's view of this information is that it is inevitable that RDP will be enhanced so much in the near future that ICA will loose it's edge in the presentation protocol market. Warren even suggests that Citrix will probably have no choice but to open up the specification of ICA as well. While I feel that this might be a bit of a premature prediction to make, I do agree that ICA will get some fierce competition in the near future, more than they have had so far.

In order to keep the edge that ICA currently has, Citrix needs to keep adding features to ICA that really make a difference. One problem that I could foresee is that Citrix is kind of the victim of their own success. ICA is already so advanced that other additions would probably fall in the category nice-to-have as opposed to must-have. I've seen this happen in Presentation Server as well. Let me give an example: when Citrix introduced 16 bit color as opposed to 256 color this was a must-have. When Citrix introduced 256 bit encryption as opposed to-whatever-number-it was-earlier this was something that would fall in the nice-to-have-category. 

Anyway, exiting times lie ahead. Whatever happens, I'm sure this will be a win-win for users of presentation protocols.


Related Items:

Microsoft Acquires Calista Technologies (21 January 2008)
Citrix Project Apollo Demo From Summit 08 (4 February 2008)
VMware's Response To Microsoft's VDI Offensive (28 January 2008)
Microsoft Enters VDI Market By Tag-Teaming With Citrix (22 January 2008)
VMware View4 and PCoIP By Mike Laverick (23 November 2009)
Connection Broker Review (VMware, Citrix, VAS and Leostream) (10 January 2008)
Citrix Acquires XenSource For $500 Million (15 August 2007)
Windows 7 RDP Improvements: What's In Your Face? (26 November 2008)
Brian Madden Overviews Callista As Details Start To Emerge (25 June 2009)
VMPerfMon: Measure Real Usage Within A VM (24 August 2006)
Comments (0)